Site Navigation

Name: Old World Creamery
Address: 1606 Erie Ave, Sheboygan, WI, 53081, US
Telephone: (920) 550-4443

Home
About
Services
Testimonials
Contact
News

Old World Creamery

"The Butter Choice"

About Us

Old World Creamery – A Scoop of Nostalgia, A Dash of Delight!

Step into Old World Creamery, where timeless charm meets tasty treats! We’re your neighborhood destination for creamy indulgence, cozy vibes, and now… $.25 scoops of Cedar Crest ice cream—a local legend in every lick!

Whether you're craving a quick pick-me-up or a sweet stroll down memory lane, we’ve got you covered. Come for the classic creamery feel, stay for the unbeatable scoop deal. Because at Old World Creamery, happiness is just a quarter away!

Interested in our Retail Store? Give us a call at 920.593.9999 or visit us through our website!

Areas Served

Our Certifications

Safe Quality Food Institute - SQFI
Certified Organic by MOSA

Languages Spoken

English
Spanish

What We Offer

Our Specialties include:

Butter
Cheese
Cream Cheese

Our Brands include:

Cedar Crest

Our Products include:

Dairy Products
Gift Items
Magnets
Cutting Boards
Bobble Heads
Olives
Jarred Asparagus
Jams
Amish Candy
Cheese Fudge
Cheese Balls
Grilled Cheese
$0.25 Ice Cream Scoops from our local partner Cedar Crest!

Testimonials

On 12/5/2025 Steven Thimmig had this to say:
Great deals on great products. The clerk was super helpful. Highly recommend this establishment.

On 12/4/2025 Lisa Ladd had this to say:
Everything is better with butter! And butter is better at Old World Creamery! Also, cream cheese! The staff are always friendly and helpful. The ice cream is delicious and the price cannot be beat. I stop here often to buy things for myself and buy gifts for friends and family. Testimonial written by Lisa Ladd on this site.

On 12/1/2025 Darlene Henning had this to say:
This was such a pleasant place to stop. The gentleman who help us did such a good job. The little store had a very good offering of things to buy and the prices were not out of line. Loved the antique decor as well.

On 10/22/2025 Mark had this to say:
Great outlet store Testimonial written by Mark on this site.

On 10/6/2025 Kathy O'Brien had this to say:
friendly staff and great prices on butter! A large cheese assortment. Testimonial written by Kathy O'Brien on this site.

Contact Us

Old World Creamery
1606 Erie Ave Sheboygan, WI 53081
Phone: (920) 550-4443
Email: info@owcreamery.com

Conveniently located on Highway 23

Where To Find Us

Payment Types Accepted

Discover, American Express, Debit Cards, MasterCard, Visa

Our Hours

Holiday Hours May Vary. Please Call For Details.

Monday: 8:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Tuesday: 8:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Wednesday: 8:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Thursday: 8:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Friday: 8:00 AM - 4:30 PM
Saturday: 8:00 AM - 12:00 PM

News

This Thanksgiving season, we’re thankful for our amazing customers and the joy of sharing great food. Whether you’re picking up a sweet treat or stocking up on dairy products for your holiday recipes, Old World Creamery is your one-stop shop for flavor and charm. Come in and celebrate the season with us!
#ThankfulForFlavor #OldWorldCreamery #HolidayCooking #WisconsinDairy #ProteinSnacks #FruitSmoothies #GratitudeSeason

Looking for fun and flavorful finds? October is the perfect time to explore our gift items, including magnets, cutting boards, and bobble heads, alongside tasty treats like jarred asparagus, olives, and our famous grilled cheese. And don’t forget—$0.25 ice cream scoops from our local partner Cedar Crest are always a hit!
#OctoberTreats #OldWorldCreamery #CedarCrestIceCream #GrilledCheeseLove #UniqueGifts #WisconsinMade #FallFun

Fall is here, and it’s the perfect time to cozy up with comforting flavors! At Old World Creamery, we offer more than just premium butter—explore our selection of cheese balls, cheese fudge, and Amish candy for a truly indulgent experience. Whether you're cooking, snacking, or gifting, we’ve got something delicious waiting for you.

Discover the taste of tradition with Old World Creamery! Our artisanal cheeses are crafted with care using time-honored methods. From creamy cheddar to tangy blue, we have something for every cheese lover. Try our products today!

Spread the love with Old World Creamery cream cheese! Perfect for romantic dinners or sharing with loved ones, our cheeses bring people together. Celebrate special moments with our delicious products.